Cash Against Documents (CAD) in Export-Import Trade

 

Cash Against Documents (CAD) is a widely used payment method in international trade. It is an arrangement where the exporter ships goods to the importer and provides the shipping and title documents to a bank. The bank releases these documents to the importer only upon payment of the invoice amount. CAD is considered a secure payment mechanism that balances the risks between buyers and sellers.

Definition

Cash Against Documents is a type of Documentary Collection where banks act as intermediaries to collect payment from the importer in exchange for shipping documents. The exporter’s bank forwards the documents to the importer’s bank, which releases them to the importer only after payment is made.

Key Features of CAD

1. Bank as an Intermediary: Banks facilitate the exchange of documents and payment but do not guarantee the payment.
2. Shipping Before Payment: The exporter ships goods before receiving payment but retains control over the goods through documents.
3. Payment on Document Release: The importer must pay to obtain the documents necessary to claim the goods.
4. Cost-Effective: CAD transactions are generally less expensive than Letters of Credit (LC) as they involve fewer formalities and lower bank charges.

Parties Involved

1. Exporter: The seller who ships the goods and instructs their bank to release documents upon payment.
2. Importer: The buyer who pays to receive the documents and take possession of the goods.
3. Exporter’s Bank (Remitting Bank): Facilitates the process by sending the documents to the importer’s bank.
4. Importer’s Bank (Collecting Bank): Holds the documents and releases them to the importer upon payment.

Process of CAD Transactions

1. Sales Agreement: The exporter and importer agree on the terms of sale, including the use of CAD as the payment method.
2. Shipment of Goods: The exporter ships the goods and obtains the necessary documents, such as the bill of lading, invoice, and packing list.
3. Submission of Documents: The exporter submits the documents to their bank (remitting bank) with instructions for payment collection.
4. Forwarding Documents: The remitting bank forwards the documents to the importer’s bank (collecting bank).
5. Notification to Importer: The collecting bank informs the importer about the arrival of documents.
6. Payment by Importer: The importer makes the payment to the collecting bank to obtain the documents.
7. Release of Documents: Once payment is received, the collecting bank releases the documents to the importer, who can then claim the goods.

Advantages of CAD

1. For Exporters:

   • Retains control over goods until payment is received.
   • Cost-effective compared to Letters of Credit.
   • Simple and efficient process.

2. For Importers:

   • No advance payment is required.
   • Payment is made only after shipment confirmation.
   • Lower banking fees compared to LC.

---

Disadvantages of CAD

1. For Exporters:

   • Risk of non-payment if the importer refuses to pay.
   • Limited recourse in case of disputes.
   • Delays in payment due to banking processes.

2. For Importers:

   • Limited inspection of goods before payment.
   • Reliance on the exporter’s compliance with agreed terms.

Documents Typically Involved

1. Bill of Lading: Acts as proof of shipment and title of goods.
2. Commercial Invoice: Specifies the goods and payment amount.
3. Packing List: Details the contents of the shipment.
4. Certificate of Origin: Indicates the country of manufacture.
5. Insurance Certificate: Provides coverage for transit risks (if applicable).

Comparison: CAD vs. Letter of Credit

Aspect	Cash Against Documents (CAD)	Letter of Credit (LC)
Payment Security	Moderate	High (bank guarantees payment)
Cost	Lower (fewer bank charges)	Higher (extensive documentation and fees)
Complexity	Simpler process	Involves multiple formalities
Risk to Exporter	Risk of non-payment by importer	Minimal (bank assumes payment responsibility)
Risk to Importer	Must pay before inspecting goods	Reduced risk; terms are detailed in LC

---

Challenges in CAD Transactions

1. Non-Payment Risk: The importer may refuse to pay, leaving the exporter with undelivered goods at a foreign port.
2. Shipping Delays: If delays occur, the importer might lose interest in the transaction.
3. Disputes: Disagreements over goods or terms may arise post-payment, with limited dispute resolution mechanisms.
4. Currency Fluctuations: Variations in exchange rates may affect the final payment value.

Best Practices for CAD

1. Clear Agreements: Ensure terms of sale, payment timelines, and responsibilities are well-documented in the sales contract.
2. Choose Reliable Partners: Work with trusted importers and banks to reduce risks.
3. Use Insurance: Insure goods against transit risks and potential losses.
4. Monitor Payment Deadlines: Set reminders to ensure timely payment by the importer.

Suitability of CAD

Cash Against Documents is best suited for:

• Transactions with medium trust between parties.
• Moderate-value goods where neither party wants the expense of an LC.
• Situations where the importer has sufficient liquidity to pay on demand.

Conclusion

Cash Against Documents is an efficient and cost-effective payment mechanism for international trade. While it provides a balanced level of security for both exporters and importers, it is essential to mitigate risks through careful partner selection, clear contractual terms, and proper use of insurance. By understanding its mechanism and applying best practices, businesses can leverage CAD to streamline their export-import operations.